Why do people want to watch a Tom Cruise movie? Mostly because Tom Cruise is in it. That's why his face is on the poster, and his name is above the title.
With AI, it's now possible to make a Tom Cruise movie without Tom Cruise. Someone could use AI to copy his face, his voice, and the way he moves, and make it look as though he had acted in a movie he never made. Most people would agree that it would be wrong to do this without the actor's consent — that someone who did that would be using something of the actor's that they didn't have a right to.
The most natural word for the thing being used is the actor's “persona”.
Until now we didn't have to distinguish explicitly between a performer and their persona. Before AI, you couldn't get one without the other. Now that you can, we need to be clear about what personas are and how they should be used.
This has happened before. When photography arrived, people began to find their pictures used in ways they had never agreed to, and the law had to recognise something called a person's likeness.
A persona is this concept expanded for the age of AI. A persona is everything about a person that makes them recognisable as themselves: their likeness, voice, speech mannerisms, posture, gestures, and movements.
An actor’s smile is part of their persona. So is the way their voice sounds on a high note. There's no need for a complete list. You already know what a persona is: it's whatever makes you think, ‘That's Tom Cruise.’
Actors are more than their personas. They are living, breathing human beings with professional and public reputations, personalities, skills, political views, and private lives. A persona is not the whole person. It is the recognisable part of them that can be imitated or reproduced.
An actor's persona is also distinct from the characters they play. Character and persona combine to create what the audience sees, but although they can blend together at the edges, they're fundamentally separate.
When Tom Cruise appears in a movie, the production may own the script, the costume designs, and the rights to the character. But it didn’t create Tom Cruise’s face, voice, or mannerisms. He brought those with him.
The character belongs to the production. The persona belongs to the performer.
Why is it wrong to use someone's persona without their consent? Not only because it might damage their reputation or deprive them of income, though it can do both, but because your persona is part of who you are. Faking you without your consent is a violation of your autonomy.
That doesn’t mean that all imitation should be forbidden. An impression, caricature, or parody is one thing. Making audiences believe that you performed in something you didn’t is quite another.
Performers own their personas, and they should control how they are used.
This isn't a new idea either. Performers have always controlled their personas, without having to think about it. You couldn't be in a movie without turning up, and nobody could get you there without paying you and agreeing a contract. AI has changed that, so control must now be exercised deliberately.
AI brings opportunities as well as dangers. Some performers will never want their persona reproduced. Others will be happy to let it appear in a soft drink ad on the other side of the world, and to be paid without having to fly there.
Even performers who are firmly against AI clones will usually prefer a small fix in post-production to travelling across the country to reshoot four seconds of a film they have already made. The important thing is the choice should be theirs.
None of this is beyond us. We already have systems for licensing music, images, and other intellectual property. We can build something similar for personas, provided we get the underlying principles right.
Before AI, you controlled your persona without even thinking about it. Now you have to decide. You can choose for it never to be reproduced, or you can choose to say yes to some uses and no to others.
But you can only choose what happens to your persona if you control it.